Cassandra Spender
During my last several abductions, I have experienced no fear whatsoever. And it was the absence of fear that allowed me... To communicate with them, and them with me. They've told me that I am an apostle, here to spread the word of a dawning of a new age of supernatural enlightenment.
Lagerqvist
Sensibly, it's not a question of truth versus fiction... But of truths which are incomprehensible, because we have no physics, no real language... For explaining patient x's story, much less the existence of extraterrestrials. Nothing to prepare us for the ontological shock that is bound to follow.
Woman
We quibble and we jaw about the need for proof, for evidence, as if it would serve some purpose, as if it would make a difference. When what we should be seeking is exactly... What this woman is describing-- not if they are here but why... And what their business is.
Fazio
In my conversations with her, she believes this business-- the abductions and the experiments-- are due to their plans for us. And that we are not simply breeding cows for them, as some have suggested, but subjects. Much like we think of our relationship with God. And that there are sights... What she calls "lighthouses" around which will be great activity.
Fox Mulder
All-- all this conjecture-- the ontological shock that you speak of-- for which we are so ill-equipped is, in my opinion, not only false but dangerous. This woman-- this woman presents no good or credible testimony... Apart from the feel-good message that she promotes.
Fazio
You think she's lying?
Fox Mulder
No, I don't think she's lying. I think... That if you prepare people well enough to believe a lie, they will believe it as if it were true. And if you tell them a really big lie-- like there are aliens from outer space-- much more than a small one, they will believe it. And if you suggest to them that these aliens are doing bad things to them, the power of this suggestion will be to make certain people believe... That certain psychopathologies and neuroses that they're suffering from... Can now be attributed to that.
Lagerqvist
Mr. Mulder-- agent Mulder, she has physical ailments.
Woman
Are you discounting any belief in the existence of extraterrestrials?
Fox Mulder
No, I just question mindless belief.
Fazio
But you've cited evidence. You've made claims yourself.
Fox Mulder
What I've seen, I've seen because I wanted to believe. I-- if you look too hard, you can go mad. But if you continue to look, you become liberated and you come awake, as if from a dream, realizing that-- that the lies are there... Simply to protect what they're advertising-- a government which knows that its greatest strength... Is not in defense but in attack.
Fox Mulder
It's strongly held by believers in UFO phenomena... That there is military complicity or involvement in abductions. But what if there is no complicity? What if there is simply just the military seeking to develop an arsenal of weapons... Against which there is no defense? Biological warfare, which justifies in their eyes... Making an ass out of the nation with stories of little green men. A conspiracy wrapped in a plot inside a government agenda.
Fox Mulder
Dr. Werber?
Dr. Heitz Werber
It's been some time.
Fox Mulder
Almost five years.
Dr. Heitz Werber
I came down expecting to hear... How your work had progressed. I'm... Surprised, to say the least.
Fox Mulder
A lot has changed.
Dr. Heitz Werber
You seem to have abandoned something you believed so completely. In spite of what I know about you, from our work together, the memories I helped you recover about the experience with your sister.
Fox Mulder
Well, I've come to distrust a lot of things. I've-- I've come to distrust those memories.
Dr. Heitz Werber
I'm sorry.
Fox Mulder
For what?
Dr. Heitz Werber
I've taken a lot of criticism for my work with alien abductees and in the field itself. The regression hypnosis work I did with you--
Fox Mulder
No, I'm not questioning your methods, dr. Werber. I'm questioning myself and how I was tricked. How I was led to believe, through an elaborate staging of events, that my sister had been abducted.
Dr. Heitz Werber
A man with faith can indulge in the luxury of skepticism.
Fox Mulder
I don't think you understand. There's just too much evidence that it's all been a lie. The conspiracy is not to hide the existence of extraterrestrials. It's to make people believe in it so completely that they question nothing.
Dr. Heitz Werber
So, you and I have just been advocates of insanity all along? Is this the extreme possibility you believe in now?
Fox Mulder
Yeah. Is patient x any more credible?
Dr. Heitz Werber
I hope so. I'm her doctor. I think you should meet her. I think you might change your mind.