BOGGSXFILES
TRUTH STILL MATTERS
Transcripts / Season 4 / Gethsemane
Season 4 · Episode 24

Gethsemane

Character-labelled dialogue prepared from the official DVD subtitle track.

Production code4X24Original airdate · May 18, 1997
258 dialogue entries
Scene 01

Opening scene

Panelist (television)

"each passing year has seen... "our estimate of the probability of life in space increase, "along with our capabilities of detecting it. "more and more scientists feel that contact with other civilizations... "is no longer something beyond our dreams, "but is a natural event in the history of mankind... That will, perhaps, occur within the lifetime of many of us."

[ people chattering, indistinct ]

Voice

All right, great. Tell him to come on in.

Scene 02

MULDER'S APARTMENT

Dana Scully

Excuse me.

Voice

Make way. Let her through.

Detective Rempulski

Agent Scully? Detective rempulski, alexandria p.d. Thanks for coming down to do this. It him?

Dana Scully

Yeah.

Scene 03

FBI HEADQUARTERS

Scott Blevins

Agent Scully, please have a seat. Agent Scully, we've had a brief discussion, but will you restate the matter we're here to put to rest?

Dana Scully

Yes, sir. Four years ago, section chief Blevins assigned me to a project you all know as the X-Files. As I am a medical doctor with a background in hard science, my job was to provide an analytical perspective... On the work of special agent Fox Mulder... Whose investigations into the paranormal... Were fueled by a personal belief... That his sister had been abducted by aliens when he was 12. I come here today, four years later, to report on the illegitimacy of agent Mulder's work. It is my scientific opinion... That he became, over the course of these years, a victim-- a victim of his own false hopes... And of his belief... In the biggest of lies.

Scene 04

SAINT ELIAS MOUNTAINS YUKON TERRITORY, CANADA

Dr. Arlinsky

We're meeting the guide at base camp. He'll take us to the site.

Babcock

Has he seen it?

Dr. Arlinsky

Oh, yeah. He said it's unbelievable.

Babcock

How soon can we get to the site?

Man

Right now? We'd be pushing it to be up top by nightfall.

Babcock

I'd rather sleep seeing it than lay awake all night wondering.

Man

It's gonna take some work.

Dr. Arlinsky

I've waited all my life for this day.

Babcock

Let's do it.

Man

Over here!

Dr. Arlinsky

How you doin'?

Man

Hello.

Expedition Members

I assume you're okay. Nice to meet you. George.

Dr. Arlinsky

My God. It's beautiful.

Scene 05

FBI HEADQUARTERS

Scott Blevins

Agent Scully, I presume you have a basis... For this break from agent Mulder.

Dana Scully

Yes, sir. Recent events have shed new light... On the factual and physical evidence... That would serve to prove the existence of extraterrestrial life, which is the foundation of agent Mulder's consuming devotion to his work.

Scott Blevins

What factual evidence?

Dana Scully

Agent Mulder was recently contacted by a man... Whose pursuit of this evidence seemed to coincide with his own. In his intense desire to believe, agent Mulder was duped by this man. He was fooled by an act of scientific sleight of hand... Calculated to perpetuate false truths, the larger lie. I am here today to expose this lie, to show the mechanism of deception... That drew him and me into it... And to expose agent Mulder's work for what it is. And grabbing him by the knees, then him falling backwards,

Scene 06

MRS SCULLY"S HOUSE

[ knocking ]

Dana Scully

Tumbling over me and down the stairs.

Margaret Scully

Hi.

Dana Scully

Speaking of Bill, is he coming?

Household Staff

Good evening. May I take your coat?

Bill Scully Jr.

Thank you.

Margaret Scully

There he is.

Dana Scully

[ laughing ] hi.

Bill Scully Jr.

Hello, Dana.

Dana Scully

Look at you. Look at you, my big brother.

Bill Scully Jr.

I'm sorry I'm late. My ship got stuck in traffic.

[ chuckling ]

Bill Scully Jr.

Did you get my birthday card?

Dana Scully

Yes, I did. Thanks for remembering this year.

Bill Scully Jr.

Once a decade.

Margaret Scully

Father McCue, I've been waiting for you.

Bill Scully Jr.

How you feeling, Dana?

Dana Scully

I'm fine. Let's get some dinner, huh?

Bill Scully Jr.

Yeah, I'm starving.

Margaret Scully

You came just in time.

[ guests chuckling ]

Bill Scully Jr.

So the parrot says, "I only got one question: what did that chicken in there do?"

[ laughing ]

Bill Scully Jr.

Mom, I'll open some more wine.

Margaret Scully

Okay.

Father McCue

[ sighs ] I feel awkward sitting here. I'm sure you do too.

Dana Scully

No. I'm sorry.

Father McCue

I've known your family for so many years. Your mother asked me to come, that I might have a word with you. I know it's been some time since we've spoken ourselves, since you drifted from the church.

Dana Scully

Father McCue--

Father McCue

But at a time of personal crisis, a threat to your health, turning back to your faith is important and essential.

Dana Scully

Father McCue... I appreciate my mother's concern... And yours, but I'm being treated for my cancer, and I'm taking every precaution.

Father McCue

Faith can make you stronger.

Dana Scully

I haven't felt a need. I have strength, and-- [ phone rings ] and I'm not going to come running back now. It's just not who I am. I'd be lying to myself and to you.

Bill Scully Jr.

Dana. Phone.

Dana Scully

Excuse me. Hello.

Fox Mulder

Scully, it's me. Sorry to interrupt your dinner.

Dana Scully

No, is something the matter?

Fox Mulder

I need your help on something. Somebody named Arlinski just contacted me at the smithsonian.

Dana Scully

Contacted you about what?

Fox Mulder

About something he found on a mountain in Canada.

Dana Scully

What?

Fox Mulder

I'd rather not talk about it over the phone. I just need you to meet me at the smithsonian.

Dana Scully

When?

Fox Mulder

Right away.

Dana Scully

I'm on my way.

Scene 07

SMITHSONIAN

Fox Mulder

I'm gonna have to apologize to your brother and mother. This is something that just couldn't wait, though.

Dana Scully

It's okay. Who is this Arlinski?

Fox Mulder

He's a forensics anthropologist that I've been in contact with over the past four years. Several years ago he was involved in a UFO photo enhancement scandal, but he continues to profess his innocence.

Dana Scully

What am I coming to see?

Fox Mulder

I'm not going to tell you. I want you to decide for yourself.

Scene 08

LAB

Dr. Arlinsky

By my rough estimate, from the sediment in our ice core samples, the body you're looking at is over 200 years old.

Fox Mulder

It looks perfectly intact.

Dr. Arlinsky

Yeah.

Fox Mulder

That doesn't make sense. There would have been signs of predation.

Dr. Arlinsky

Yeah, but the position he was found in, stuffed in a crevice at high altitude, he may have frozen fast enough to avoid being eaten.

Fox Mulder

Does that fit geologically?

Dr. Arlinsky

The area where he was found... Is in the terminal moraine of a glacier which has since receded. Two hundred years ago, the area where he was frozen was within the tree line. There would have been a thaw.

Dana Scully

Who found him?

Dr. Arlinsky

A Canadian geodetic survey team. Along with a colleague of mine named Babcock, they're all still up there on the mountain.

Fox Mulder

Who else knows about this? No one.

Dr. Arlinsky

I know what your first thought was, but the st. Elias range? That's a long way to go for a hoax.

Fox Mulder

If you're gonna go, why not go all the way?

Dr. Arlinsky

I'm circumspect myself, but the ice core samples I took can't be faked.

Dana Scully

You have the ice core samples here?

Dr. Arlinsky

Yeah. Yeah. One taken from each side of the body. A 360-degree matching integrity of sediment. It's my sincere belief... That what we have here... Is the complete corpus of an extraterrestrial biological entity. Absolute, and irrefutable.

Fox Mulder

Qualitatively indefensible. You go public with this, and nobody is going to believe you. You also risk never knowing because the same people who buried the truth assiduously... Will be in charge of its authentication.

Dr. Arlinsky

That's why I came to you. I need to get the specimen out so I can authenticate it. This body means everything to you, agent Mulder. You're gonna have the proof in your hands.

Fox Mulder

And what do you want?

Dr. Arlinsky

We just want the credit.

Scene 09

STAIRWAY

Fox Mulder

Do you think it's foolish?

Dana Scully

I have no opinion, actually.

Fox Mulder

You have no opinion?

Dana Scully

This is your holy grail, Mulder, not mine.

Fox Mulder

What is that supposed to mean?

Dana Scully

It just means that proving to the world the existence of alien life... Is not my last, dying wish.

Fox Mulder

How about santa claus or the easter bunny? This is not some selfish pet project of mine. I'm as skeptical of that man as you are, but definitive proof... Of sentient beings sharing time and existence with us would change everything. Every truth we live by would be shaken to the ground. There is no greater revelation imaginable, no greater scientific discovery.

Dana Scully

You already believe, Mulder. What difference will it make? What will proof change for you?

Fox Mulder

If someone could prove to you the existence of God, would it change you?

Dana Scully

Only if it had been disproven.

Fox Mulder

Then you accept the possibility that belief in God is a lie?

Dana Scully

I don't think about it, actually, and I don't think that it can be proven.

Fox Mulder

But what if it could be? Wouldn't that knowledge be worth seeking? Or is it just easier to go on believing the lie?

Dana Scully

I can't go with you, Mulder.

Fox Mulder

Can you at least take a look at those core samples and tell me if they're a lie? That's all I'm asking.

Scene 10

FBI HEADQUARTERS

Dana Scully

What I couldn't tell agent Mulder, what I had only just learned myself, was that the cancer which had been diagnosed in me several months earlier... Had metastasized. The doctors told me, short of a miracle, it would continue to aggressively invade my body, advancing faster each day towards the inevitable.

Scene 11

CAVERN

Man

What's that for?

Babcock

I don't know these men well. Do you?

Man

Well enough.

Babcock

I'm gonna be up here alone until you get back. I hope I don't have to use it.

Other Man

I think you better have a look at this. We were doing a lateral cut to the back corner... When I saw something in the ice. Right here.

Man

What do you think that is?

Babcock

I don't know. It could be a bubble, a weak spot.

Other Man

Or a casting channel, a pour hole. Liquid poured in from the side or above somehow.

Babcock

Poured from where?

Other Man

I don't know.

Babcock

The angle wouldn't make sense.

Other Man

Yeah, you're right.

Babcock

We'll never know until we get it out of there.

[ chain saw buzzing ]

Scene 12

PALEOCLIMATOLOGY LAB AMERICAN UNIVERSITY

Lab Technician

The iron concentration, density and temperature profiles are all consistent. There's a tight matrix of crystals at approximal center, suggesting the quick-freezing scenario you mentioned. Here at the terminus, you've got some particulate hydrocarbons: jet fuel pollutants found just about everywhere in the world.

Dana Scully

But not in old ice?

Lab Technician

Don't misunderstand. This is old ice. This sample has numerous layers of sedimentation, like the rings on a tree essentially.

Dana Scully

So it hasn't been tampered with?

Lab Technician

Not from what I can see. Can I ask why it is you're testing this ice?

Dana Scully

Another agent asked me to.

Lab Technician

Do you know where this sample came from?

Dana Scully

From a site in the Yukon territory. Why?

Lab Technician

There's some cellular material within the matrix.

Dana Scully

Plant or animal?

Lab Technician

I don't know. It's what I'd have to classify a chimera, a hybrid cell.

Dana Scully

From what?

Lab Technician

As I said, I don't know.

Dana Scully

Is it capable of cell division?

Lab Technician

I don't know that either. I've just now found them. I'd like to get them under our electron microscope, if that's okay.

Dana Scully

Yes, please.

[ shotgun cocks ]

Scene 13

BASE CAMP - NIGHT

Fox Mulder

I thought you said there was someone meeting us.

Dr. Arlinsky

Yeah, a guide named ralston.

Scene 14

COMMUNICATIONS TENT

Dr. Arlinsky

I don't get it. This had all been arranged. He knew he was supposed to take us up to the summit. I don't know what to do.

[ sighs ]

Dr. Arlinsky

We can probably follow this track right up to the site. Maybe we'll meet him on the way down.

Fox Mulder

Funny place to take a nap. He's been shot. Oh, God. This our guide? Yeah.

Scene 15

LAB

Dana Scully

Excuse me. I'm looking for dr. Vitagliano. Dr. Vitagliano-- is he here?

Michael Kritschgau

Uh, no, I'm afraid not.

Dana Scully

I was supposed to meet him here. Actually, I'm a little late.

Michael Kritschgau

Sorry.

[ groans ]

[ panting ]

Scene 16

BASE CAMP - NIGHT

Dr. Arlinsky

Oh, my God. They're all dead. They've been shot. Babcock! The body. It's gone. They took it! No one knew. We didn't tell a soul.

Fox Mulder

They had radio communication. Maybe it was being monitored. Wait. Shh!

[ groaning ]

[ groaning continues ]

Fox Mulder

Someone's still alive.

Dr. Arlinsky

It's Babcock.

Fox Mulder

Get me some water. It looks like he took a shotgun hit. It didn't open him up too badly. The bleeding's stopped.

Dr. Arlinsky

Who did this?

Fox Mulder

[ Mulder ] here you go. They took our body, Babcock.

Babcock

No... I buried it.

Dr. Arlinsky

Where?

Scene 17

ROOM

Bill Scully Jr.

Dana?

Dana Scully

Bill. What are you doing here?

Bill Scully Jr.

I picked up the phone when they called mom's. Said you could use a change of clothes.

Dana Scully

Thank you. Where's mom?

Bill Scully Jr.

I didn't tell mom what happened. So what did happen?

Dana Scully

I, uh-- I was knocked down a flight of stairs, but I'm okay, luckily.

Bill Scully Jr.

You're not okay, Dana. I know about your cancer.

Dana Scully

I told mom not to tell you.

Bill Scully Jr.

Why?

Dana Scully

Because it's very personal. Because I don't want sympathy.

Bill Scully Jr.

You think you can cure yourself. Mom tells me that you've gotten worse, that your cancer's gone into your bloodstream. What are you doing at work, getting knocked down and beaten up? What are you trying to prove? That you're gonna go out fighting?

Dana Scully

Come on, Bill.

Bill Scully Jr.

You know what mom's going through? Why do you think I didn't tell her when they called?

Dana Scully

What should I be doing?

Bill Scully Jr.

We have a responsibility, not just to ourselves, but to the people in our lives!

Dana Scully

Just because I haven't bared my soul to you or to father McCue or to God... Doesn't mean that I'm not responsible to what's important to me.

Bill Scully Jr.

To what? To who? This guy, Mulder? Where is he, Dana? Where is he through all this?

Dana Scully

Thank you for coming.

Bill Scully Jr.

Dana--

[ hydraulic whirring ]

Scene 18

SOUTHEAST WASHINGTON, DC

Dr. Arlinsky

We should be able to do a good enough examination of the body right here to remove any doubt.

Fox Mulder

We won't know for sure until we do a carbon dating test.

Dr. Arlinsky

I'm anticipating his physiology alone is going to be telltale.

Fox Mulder

The piltdown man hoax wasn't uncovered for 40 years... Until it failed the carbon dating test, and that wasn't even very good.

Babcock

If this were a hoax, would we have six dead men up on that mountain? Somebody other than us sure as hell believes it's not.

Scene 19

FBI SCI-CRIME LAB

Tech

As you can imagine, that's a heavily trafficked stairwell, so we went back to the bio lab where we found an anomalous set of latents. We found a partial matching in the stairwell four centimeters from one of yours.

Dana Scully

Have you run it through the n.c.I.c.?

Tech

Yep. This is your assailant. Unfortunately, he doesn't have a criminal record.

Dana Scully

Try the federal database.

Tech

I'll be damned. How'd you know it would be a government employee?

Dana Scully

Where does he work?

[ typing ]

Tech

Right here in Washington. Michael Kritschgau, formerly of the u.s. Army, now attached to the pentagon's research division in Virginia.

[ typing ]

Tech

Is this the man?

Scene 20

WAREHOUSE

Dr. Arlinsky

The body is 147 centimeters long, weighing 24 kilograms deliquesced. Derma is hairless gray with an elephantine texture with no odor. There are some small eruptions on the surface of the skin, mostly likely due to the presence of iron phosphate in the ice. Otherwise there appears to be no scarring and no identifying marks. The circumference of the head is 64 centimeters. There are four digits on each hand and three on each foot. The sex is indeterminate. The eyes are lidless black... Covered by what appears to be a thin membrane, which I am now removing. The tissue underneath... Seems to be semigelatinous.... With a fine network of veins running throughout. Examination of the chest cavity confirms the presence... Of what appears to be a cardiopulmonary system-- heart, lungs, all identifiable-- within a mass of white stringlike tissue... That doesn't appear to correspond... To human physiology.

Scene 21

DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE RESEARCH FACILITY

Dana Scully

Stop! Federal agent! Hold it! Michael Kritschgau! You are under arrest! Identify your location!

[ car engine starts ]

[ tires screeching ]

Dana Scully

Get out of the car! Now! Move!

[ turns off engine ]

Michael Kritschgau

Please don't shoot. I didn't mean to hurt you. I had no choice.

Dana Scully

Hands on the car!

Michael Kritschgau

If you arrest me, they'll kill me.

Dana Scully

I don't know what you're talking about.

Michael Kritschgau

The same people who are trying to kill you. The people who gave you your cancer.

Scene 22

WAREHOUSE

Dr. Arlinsky

There's tissue culturing to be done, DNA sequence and an analysis. We'd be wise to run a gas chromatograph and that carbon dating you suggested. But if this isn't alien, I don't know what it is.

[ cell phone ringing ]

Fox Mulder

Mulder.

Scene 23

FBI HEADQUARTERS

Dana Scully

I had reached agent Mulder in a warehouse... Just outside of Washington in sethburg, Virginia. They had managed the frozen corpse by helicopter... Down the side of the mountain... And across the Canadian border in a refrigerated truck. After conducting a limited physical examination, agent Mulder was ready to believe... That the body was that of an extraterrestrial biological entity, that he had finally found the proof which had eluded him, which would confirm not only the existence of alien life, but of his sister Samantha's abduction.

Scott Blevins

But this man Kritschgau had convinced you otherwise. How?

Dana Scully

He told me a story, which detailed point by point... The systematic way in which agent Mulder had been deceived and used, and how I, as his partner, had been led down the same path, losing a family member due to my allegiance... And contracting a fatal disease, which I was being told was engineered... By the men who are responsible for agent Mulder's deception.

Scott Blevins

Were you able to convince agent Mulder of these facts?

Dana Scully

I was only able to convince him to meet me... So that he might hear the story the way I had.

[ creaking ]

Scene 24

OUTSIDE WAREHOUSE - NIGHT

Dr. Arlinsky

Who the hell is this?

Assassin

Right there, pork. How's the wound?

Babcock

I'll live.

Dr. Arlinsky

What is this, Babcock?

Assassin

Get the door.

[ gunshot ]

Assassin

Where did Mulder go?

Babcock

He got a call.

Assassin

Is he a believer?

Babcock

Oh, yeah.

Assassin

Then we're the only ones who know.

Babcock

Right.

Michael Kritschgau

The lie you believe-- that they have cleverly led you to believe, agent Mulder-- is that there's intelligent life other than our own... And that we have had contact with these life-forms.

Fox Mulder

So you're saying this has all been orchestrated, a hoax?

Michael Kritschgau

Which you have been used to perpetuate.

Fox Mulder

You come by this knowledge how?

Michael Kritschgau

Working for the d.o.d. Watching a military industrial complex... That operated unbridled and unchecked during the cold war... Create a diversion of attention from itself and its continued misdeeds... By confabulating enough believable evidence... To convince passionate adepts like yourself that it really could be true.

Fox Mulder

And just by chance, you run into agent Scully?

[ scoffs ]

Michael Kritschgau

I was just like you, agent Mulder: suspicious of everything but what you should be. I ran the d.o.d.'s agitprop arm for a decade. I can show you records of disinformation... Dating back to the korean war, before you were born.

Fox Mulder

Why come to me now? Why not four years ago?

Michael Kritschgau

I have a son who's very sick. He served in the gulf war. The lies are so deep, the only way to cover them... Is to create something even more incredible. They invented you: your regression hypnosis, the story of your sister's abduction, the lies they fed your father. You wanted to believe so badly, and who could have blamed you?

Fox Mulder

And the thousands of UFO sightings?

Michael Kritschgau

Above-top-secret military aircraft... Concept designed to feed hysteria.

Fox Mulder

Evidence of alien biology?

Michael Kritschgau

Unclassified but naturally occurring biologic anomalies... Science will eventually explain.

Fox Mulder

The body that was found?

Michael Kritschgau

Meticulously constructed... Out of biomaterials... Created through the hybridization of differentiated cells-- what are called chimeras-- frozen into place over the course of a year... Using sediment and materials that would bear out its age, poured through a small channel drilled in the rock above.

Fox Mulder

They would have known the body would be carbon-dated, that it would be proved a fake.

Michael Kritschgau

The body will never be tested.

Fox Mulder

What do you mean?

Michael Kritschgau

You were only meant to see it... To make you believe the lie... So that you might finally commit... And go public with the news.

Fox Mulder

This man is a liar.

Michael Kritschgau

You can see for yourself, agent Mulder. The body is already long gone.

Fox Mulder

Dr. Arlinski? It's gone.

Scene 25

WAREHOUSE

Dana Scully

Mulder?

[ Mulder groans ]

Dana Scully

What?

Fox Mulder

It's Arlinski. He's dead.

Dana Scully

So is this man. Who did this, Mulder? Mulder?

Fox Mulder

What we had here was proof. There's no way it could be anything else.

Dana Scully

You said it yourself: more tests needed to be run.

Fox Mulder

But the ice core samples checked out. If the ice hasn't been tampered with, how could the body within be a fake?

Dana Scully

Cellular material found in the ice core samples... Were a direct match for what this man Kritschgau described: hybrid cells, chimeras within the matrix.

Fox Mulder

Do we know for sure those cells are not extraterrestrial?

Dana Scully

Mulder, everything this man described-- you can't just guess at these details. I'm sorry, but the facts here completely overwhelm any argument against them.

Fox Mulder

Facts overwhelmed by the lies created to support them.

Dana Scully

The only lie here is the one that you continue to believe.

Fox Mulder

After all I've seen and experienced, I refuse to believe that it's not true.

Dana Scully

Because it's easier to believe the lie, isn't it?

Fox Mulder

What the hell did that guy say to you that you believe his story?

Dana Scully

He said that the men behind this hoax... Behind these lies... Gave me this disease to make you believe.

Scene 26

MULDER'S APARTMENT

Ashley Montagu

What we generally mean is intelligent life, something resembling our noble selves. It is highly probable... That there are such intelligent forms of life... In other galaxies in the universe, and it is even more probable... That many of these forms are vastly more intelligent than we.

Another Man On Video

I think there's no question... But that we live in an inhabited universe... That has life all over it.

Carl Sagan

By finding out what the other planets are like, by finding out whether there are civilizations on planets of other stars, we reestablish a meaningful context for ourselves.

Ashley Montagu

I don't think we should wait until the encounter occurs, but that we should do all in our power to prepare ourselves for it.

Isaac Asimov

I can conceive of no nightmare as terrifying... As establishing such communication... With a so-called superior... Or, if you wish, advanced technology in outer space.

Scene 27

Scene 27

Dana Scully

Early this morning... I got a call from the police, asking me to come to agent Mulder's apartment. The detective asked me-- he needed me to identify a body.

Scott Blevins

Agent Scully--

Dana Scully

Agent Mulder died late last night... From an apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound to the head.

About this transcript

The dialogue comes from the official DVD subtitle track supplied by Boggsfiles. Speaker and scene attribution was cross-checked against character-labelled reference material. Subtitle wording is preserved while capitalization and spacing are standardized for easier reading.